Impact Storytelling
Production | Definition | Concerns + Criticism | Reports | Education + Training
Impact storytelling is expected of nonprofits, NGOs and social impact organizations today.
Before Web 2.0, stories about social impact work were reported by journalists, but Web 2.0 enabled organizations to easily and cheaply publish stories about themselves — without the the constraints of ethical journalism standards, and before ethical storytelling standards and best practices were developed.
Suddenly, publishing was no longer controlled by editors — anyone could be a publisher — and what followed has been coined the “storytelling boom”.
The storytelling boom pushed stories onto communications teams, who were already adapting to rapid changes in the media: the post, the tweet, the reel — and now, the story. Previously, storytelling had been the purview of advertising or marketing departments, and impact storytelling is still situated within many marketing departments today — a vestige of storytelling before the boom.
Typical Production Roles
NGO: Story participant
Media: Interviewee
Narratology: Protagonist
NGO: Story collector
Media: Interviewer or reporter
Narratology: n/a
NGO: Communications staff
Media: Writer or editor
Narratology: Author or Teller
NGO: Author (unless staff byline)
Media: Story subject
Narratology: Implied narrator
NGO: Donor
Media: Reader or viewer
Narratology: Audience
Ethical Concerns
The relationship between the organization and the story participant (or beneficiary) creates an inherent power imbalance, making consent complex.
The author’s bias is inherent yet not transparent.
The organization is financially incentivized to characterize the beneficiary as a victim and itself as the hero.
Criticism
Narratologists: instrumentalized stories can negatively impact identity and agency.
Program recipients: their portrayal in the story might not align with how they see themselves.
Practitioners: the production process can feel exploitative.
Social justice advocates: stories can simplify complex social issues and focus on individual actions rather than systemic problems.
Audiences: poverty porn generates a negative response.
Typical Storytelling Process
Identification: A potential story participant is identified by a staff member.
Consent: The potential participant is invited to participate in the story.
Collection: Information for the story is collected through an interview.
Production: The story is produced in written or video format.
Approval: The story is reviewed by the participant and edited or approved.
Publication: The story is published.
Typical Media Interview Process
Request: An interview request is received by a staff member.
Identification & Consent: A potential interviewee is identified and asked if they would like to participate in the media story.
Interview Prep: The interviewee is prepped for the interview by a staff member.
Interview: The interview takes place and is facilitated by a staff member.
Publication and follow-up: The story is published and shared with the interviewee.
Impact Stories are —
“Stories about real people — describing the impact of an organization’s work — narrated by that organization, and for the benefit of that organization.”
The narrator is a nonprofit, NGO or social change organization.
The protagonist is a person who has benefitted from the organization’s work or been impacted by a social issue related to the work.
The real author is someone who works for the organization, typically a communications team member.
The implied author is the organization (if written in third person) or the protagonist (if written in first person).
The story is produced in written form — with or without images — or as a narrated video.
The story is published on the organization’s website or distributed by media publications — in whole or part — as part of a press story.
The story is instrumentalized by the organizaion: used for awareness, promotional or fundraising purposes.
Industry Reports
Impact Storytelling: the Ecosystem, the Evidence and Possible Futures
UAL AKO Storytelling Institute, May 2024.
Spotlight on Impact Storytelling: Mapping and recommendations for the narrative and cultural strategies ecosystem
Liz Manne Strategy, March 2022
You’ve been reframed: How ought beneficiaries be represented in fundraising materials?
Rogare The Fundraising Think Tank, May 2020.
Education + Training
Center for Social Impact Communication
Georgetown University
Online Certificate in Social Impact Storytelling
AKO Storytelling Institute
University of the Arts London
Diploma in Storytelling